As a local builder and remodeler for nearly 30 years, HighCraft has helped countless clients improve homes to better fit their ever-evolving lives. Babies are born. Kids go off to college. Aging parents move in. Home repairs are inevitable. Life changes, and what we need from our living space changes over time.
Weigh Your Options
“If you’re wondering whether it makes more sense to remodel your current home or move somewhere new, it’s important to first understand what factors are driving your decision,” says HighCraft Project Development Manager, Zach Larrick. He encourages you to ask yourself: What’s not working in my current home? Is it space, layout, location, or lifestyle? Are these short-term frustrations or long-term needs?
Many homeowners assume they’ve outgrown their home, when in reality, they’ve just outgrown how it functions. If your current home isn’t working for you as-is, weigh the following options carefully to determine if it makes the most sense to:
1.) Remodel your existing home
2.) Move to a home that better fits your needs
3.) Move and remodel a new-to-you home
4.) Design and build a new custom home
When Remodeling Makes Sense
Remodeling allows you to keep what works—and reimagine what doesn’t—with far more customization than most resale homes offer. Consider remodeling if:
- You love the location, lot, or your neighbors.
- The home has good bones but the layout no longer works for your lifestyle.
- You have the budget to make improvements.
- You want to avoid the costs and disruption of moving.
- The value of your home is improving and you wish to further invest in your property.
- You want to maintain the low interest rate on your existing mortgage.
“You have a history with your current house,” Zach says. “It’s a known quantity, so you have a good idea about what’s working, and what isn’t. Don’t underestimate the value of good neighbors either,” Zach advises, adding that good neighbors are worth their weight in gold. “If you buy another house, you never know who your next-door neighbors are going to be.” And if your kids are school age, moving them away from their friends and neighborhood school can be disruptive.
The most common remodeling projects center around both lifestyle changes and long-term livability. “Hands down, ‘aging in place’ is the biggest remodeling request we’re seeing,” Zach says, noting the increased demand for universal design features like main-floor primary suites, zero-transition entries, wider hallways, and accessible showers that allow homeowners to stay in their homes longer.
Space is another driving factor for many families. “A smaller home that once felt cozy as newlyweds starts to feel cramped when you welcome a new baby or two,” Zach explains, which is why home additions and basement finishes are popular.
Many homeowners are also prioritizing spaces that bring people together, creating homes that serve as a welcoming hub for family gatherings. These projects often involve opening up kitchens to living areas, remodeling bathrooms, adding larger islands or dining spaces, and creating indoor-outdoor spaces for entertaining.
When Moving Makes Sense
You might consider buying another home if:
- Your ideal neighborhood has available houses in your budget.
- A move would make your commute to work or school easier.
- The new house better suits your lifestyle.
- The cost of remodeling your current home is prohibitive, or your house lacks dream-home potential because of construction or location constraints.
Selling your existing home and buying another may be the right choice if you’re ready for a change in location, lifestyle, or daily convenience, and if the cost or limitations of remodeling your current home make it less practical to achieve your goals.
Keep in mind that if you buy a new home, you often don’t know what you don’t know until long after closing. You might find that the “new” house doesn’t work for you either, and may even require its own remodel. “An experienced contractor can walk through properties with you and your realtor to discuss the pros and cons of each home, and the potential for a remodel,” Zach advises.
While most builders are not licensed realtors or professional inspectors, a team like HighCraft can offer valuable insight to help you evaluate a home and make a more informed decision alongside your realtor. “Narrow it down to your top choices and give us a call,” he says. “That’s something we’re happy to do”.
“Even if your situation points you toward a move, the Northern Colorado housing market is fairly unpredictable right now,” Zach says. “Interest rates remain high, and timing a double closing can be nerve-wracking. We recommend that you always seek professional advice from a licensed realtor and lender to help make a decision that is best for your family.”
When to Design and Build a New Custom Home
Building a custom home is often the right path when a remodel or a new-to-you-home just won’t cut it, or if you’re looking for complete control over how your home functions and feels.
Rather than working within the constraints of an existing structure, a custom build allows you to design every detail of your home—from its orientation on the lot, to the floorplan, flow, and finishes. It also becomes a more practical option when your current home lacks the structural integrity, layout potential, or location advantages needed to justify a significant remodel. In these cases, starting fresh can provide greater long-term value, fewer compromises, and a home that’s truly tailored to you.
Some people hear the words “custom home” and think large, luxurious, and out of reach, “but that’s not always the case,” Zach explains. “While it’s true that some clients want lavish features and a larger footprint, others are looking for something more modest in scale and finish.”
HighCraft’s architects, interior designers and expert craftspeople have been remodeling homes since 1998, and we build and design custom homes, large and small. With decades of experience designing and building custom homes across Northern Colorado—in both urban and mountain communities—Zach notes that the goal is always the same: “What’s most important to our team is providing an exceptional experience for each client and delivering a home that’s thoughtfully designed and uniquely personal.”
When considering a custom home build, keep in mind that building new construction typically requires a longer timeline from design through construction, so it’s not the quickest path to a finished home. Planning can be complex, and the involved decision-making can feel overwhelming without the right guidance.
Talk to Professionals Early
No matter which option you choose, it’s never too early to ask a realtor about how a remodel might affect your property value, or whether it makes more sense to sell and buy or build a new home. It’s smart to discuss funding options with a lender or financial advisor, too.
Before making a decision, it’s important to understand what’s truly possible, what it will cost, and how it will serve you over time. A feasibility assessment conducted by a design-build firm like HighCraft can help evaluate your home, property, and local regulations to determine what can be achieved.
From there, thoughtful budget guidance provides clear investment ranges based on your goals, helping you compare options with confidence. “If you’re even remotely thinking about a major remodel, it’s never too early to talk to a builder about your project, and see if the remodel is realistic given your location and budget,” Zach says.
The earlier you start the conversation, the more options you have. “We love it when homeowners start the entire process early,” Zach adds. “It gives everyone time to talk through your options, and create a plan that’s right for you without feeling rushed.”
Long-term planning ensures your decision supports not just your immediate needs, but how you want to live in your home for years to come.
The Power of Planning
“Planning is the secret sauce,” Zach says. “I’ve said it before, and I’ll say it again—it’s so much easier and cheaper to move a wall on paper than during construction.” He emphasizes that thoughtful preparation leads to a smoother, more efficient process with fewer surprises along the way. “Choose the option that feels best for you,” Zach adds, whether that means remodeling, moving, or building new.
Bottom line, when it comes to improving your living space, there’s no one-size-fits-all answer. But with the right guidance, you can make a decision that supports your lifestyle, your investment, and your future.
~~~
Whether you’re developing plans for a custom home, or want to reimagine the space you have with a remodel, HighCraft’s experienced design-build team can navigate every detail of the planning and construction process for projects of any size. Contact HighCraft with questions or to schedule a free consultation.
