Should You Remodel? The Cost vs. Value Debate
You already
knew that the house needed new paint. Then you began to notice the
worn carpeting. After the washing machine flooded the laundry room and
the TV gave up for good, you found yourself thinking about maintenance
plus some remodeling. You realize that by bumping out that wall, you
could add a bathroom on the other side of the laundry room and a home
theater on the other side of the family room. Maybe even a guest room
above. The family is ecstatic. The two of you have always been movie
fans and the kids can't wait for the wide screen plasma TV. You know
that your mom will love having a room of her own when she visits. So
you sit down with pencil and paper to figure out a budget when it hits
you: how will this potential remodel affect the value of your home? If
you sold your house after improving it, would you be able to recoup
your investment? This is known as the "cost vs. value" debate.
Will the cost of the remodel add to the value of your home, and if so,
how much? To start with, remember that a well-maintained house will
always be more valuable than a "fixer-upper," even in a down market,
so new paint, carpet, and up-to-date appliances are likely to preserve
or raise the value of your home. But what about additions, major
upgrades or reconfigurations of existing rooms? Remodeling magazine
publishes an annual "cost vs. value" survey, in which real estate
agents and other experts in 60 markets nationwide estimate the
one-year payback of various remodeling projects. The magazine
concludes that the average return on investment is about 83 percent --
i.e., you won't break even -- if you sell your home within a year of
completing the project. So if you are considering selling your home
within a year, you may not retrieve a dollar for dollar pay back. It
is more typical for our clients who remodel to wait several years
before they sell. As an example, if you waited five years before
selling and assuming average appreciation, industry data suggests that
you are more likely to recoup your entire investment and in some cases
more. In the meantime, you enjoy an enhanced lifestyle and quality of
life. In addition, the cost vs. value survey changes from year to
year. Just five years ago, for instance, a modest bath remodel showed
an average estimated payback of only 85 percent. Then in 2005, that
payback jumped to 102 percent. During the same time period, a
mid-range master suite addition dipped from an 87 percent payback to
82 percent. All of these figures are national averages, so you can
expect local variations depending on housing demands and types of
projects. Although the "cost vs. value" debate is appropriate as you
consider your project, it is only one factor in your decision-making
process. By putting the tastes and wishes of a theoretical buyer (at a
theoretical time in the future) before the tastes and wishes of your
family, you may compromise the value of your investment for your
family. What if an expert could prove to you that a rec room with a
wet bar would add more value to the resale value of your house than a
home theater? Of what worth is that investment to your family if you
don't want a rec room with a wet bar? So gather the family around. Pull out
the magazines and talk about how you like to live and what would make
your home more valuable to you. Use the "cost vs. value"
debate to roughly cross check your conclusions and, if appropriate,
take the plunge. After all, it's your life!
Warm regards,
 
Dwight
Sailer & Bryan Soth
HighCraft Builders
429 S. Howes Street
Fort Collins, CO 80521
970.472.8100 - phone
info@highcraft.net
www.highcraft.net
c.
2008
All rights reserved.
|